How to use "a telltale sign"

What Does "a telltale sign" Mean?

• Meaning of the collocation or phrasal verb "A telltale sign" refers to a clear and obvious indicator or clue that reveals something, often something that is not immediately apparent or is being concealed. It suggests that the sign is revealing or giving away information.
• Whether meaning is compositional or semi-idiomatic The meaning is semi-idiomatic. While "sign" has its literal meaning, "telltale" adds a specific connotation of revealing something hidden or providing evidence of something.
• Register: formal / informal / neutral The register is neutral. It can be used in both formal and informal contexts.

How to Use It

• Grammatical pattern: adjective + noun
• Typical objects, complements, or prepositions that follow: The phrase usually stands alone as a subject, object, or complement within a sentence. It can be followed by a prepositional phrase (e.g., "a telltale sign of trouble").
• Can the components be separated? (for phrasal verbs) This is not a phrasal verb, so the components cannot be separated.
• What sounds unnatural: wrong verb, wrong preposition, wrong object Using a synonym for "telltale" that doesn't convey the sense of revelation or obviousness would sound unnatural. For example, saying "a visible sign" doesn't carry the same weight. Incorrect prepositions (e.g., "a telltale sign for something") would also be incorrect.

Real-World Examples

These examples are sourced from a telltale sign on Ludwig.guru.

"There is always a telltale sign"." — The New York Times - Arts

"These "microcalcifications" can be a telltale sign of breast cancer." — Harvard University

"It was, she said, a telltale sign of pre-eclampsia." — The New York Times - Magazine

"Crucially, they showed no amyloid plaques, a telltale sign of Alzheimer's in both mice and men." — The Economist

"Experts consider the lack of provenance a telltale sign that the works were probably plundered." — The New York Times - Arts Examples sourced from https://ludwig.guru/s/a+telltale+sign

Similar Phrases and Alternatives

Phrase	Context
clear indication	A more formal and direct alternative.
obvious sign	Emphasizes the ease of noticing the sign.
giveaway	A more informal term, often used to describe something that reveals a secret.
red flag	Indicates a warning sign or potential problem.
smoking gun	Refers to irrefutable evidence of wrongdoing.
a sure sign	Implies a high degree of certainty associated with the sign.
early warning sign	Suggests that the sign appears before a problem becomes severe.

Common Mistakes

• Learners might use a synonym for "telltale" that doesn't quite capture the sense of revelation, such as "visible sign" when "a telltale sign" is more appropriate.
• Using "telltale" as a verb is incorrect; it functions as an adjective in this collocation. The correct use is always with a noun, such as "sign."
• Attempting to separate "telltale" and "sign" would be grammatically incorrect, as it functions as a single adjectival phrase modifying the noun.

Quick-Reference Summary

Expression	Meaning	Grammatical Pattern	Register
a telltale sign	A clear and obvious indicator or clue that reveals something.	adjective + noun	Neutral

FAQs

Can "telltale" and "sign" be separated in the phrase "a telltale sign"?

No, "telltale" and "sign" cannot be separated. The phrase "a telltale sign" functions as a single unit, where "telltale" is an adjective modifying the noun "sign." Separating them would disrupt the meaning and grammatical structure.

---

How does "a telltale sign" differ from "a clear sign"?

While both phrases indicate something is noticeable, "a telltale sign" implies that the sign reveals something that might otherwise be hidden or not immediately obvious. "A clear sign" simply means that something is easily seen or understood, without necessarily implying any hidden information being revealed.

---

What's a common mistake people make when using "telltale sign"?

A common mistake is misunderstanding the function of "telltale" and either using an inappropriate synonym that doesn't convey the same sense of revelation or attempting to use "telltale" as a verb. Remember, in this context, "telltale" is an adjective that modifies the noun "sign," so using it as a verb (e.g., "the evidence telltales that...") is incorrect.